Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
-
Speaking about falling gas prices during a stop in Kansas City, Mo., President Joe Biden said, “We’re making progress. We’re going to keep at it to ensure the American people are paying their fair share for gas — not being gouged for gas.”
-
On social media, conservative media and Republican lawmakers shared a shortened clip that cut out the words, “not being gouged for gas.” In a tweet responding to the viral clip, a White House spokesperson called the omission “deceptive.”
Conservative media outlets and a number of Republican lawmakers are sharing a misleading, abbreviated clip of President Joe Biden talking about gas prices during a recent address.
The shortened clip they’re circulating make it seem as though Biden said the high prices at the gas pump in recent months are what Americans should be paying, or that they should pay more.
The full video of Biden’s speech shows him saying something different — that he wants to make sure that Americans are "not being gouged for gas."
The remarks in question came as Biden visited Kansas City, Mo., on Dec. 8 to promote the new bipartisan infrastructure law he signed in November.
Here’s what he said on gas prices, in context and with the relevant portion bolded:
"Two weeks ago, I announced the largest-ever release of the U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve to increase the supply of oil to help bring down prices. And I met with our friends around the world. Other countries joined us.
"And those savings are starting to reach drivers. Now, today, the average price you’re paying here in Kansas City is below $2 a gallon, $3 dollars a gallon. It’s down to $2.90 a gallon, 20% down from — cents (down) from — a month ago.
"Nationally, prices are down 7 cents a gallon and continue to fall. We’re making progress. We’re going to keep at it to ensure the American people are paying their fair share for gas — not being gouged for gas."
The full context of Biden’s Dec. 8 remarks indicates that he was talking about working to lower the price of gas to a more reasonable amount for Americans, not raise or maintain it. The line was met with applause from the crowd at the Kansas City Area Transportation Authority.
But conservatives media sites, pundits and politicians framed the Democratic president’s words differently on Twitter. They shared a shortened clip from the remarks that cut out Biden’s final words — "not being gouged for gas" — and left a misleading impression.
Posts sharing similarly trimmed videos or incomplete quotes also spread widely on Facebook and Instagram, where they got tens of thousands of interactions, according to CrowdTangle, a social media insights tool. They were flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook.)
Most responsible for the spread of the abbreviated clip on Twitter was the conservative website Townhall, according to Hoaxy, a social media analysis tool that maps the spread of tweets.
The website tweeted the clip just after 4 p.m. EST, writing, "BIDEN: ‘We're making progress. We're going to keep at it to ensure the American people are paying their fair share for gas.’"
In the minutes that followed, another conservative website, the Post Millennial, uploaded a similarly abbreviated clip. Disclose.tv followed suit. And the retweets rolled in:
"Hear that Americans? You're simply paying your ‘fair share’ at the gas pump now," wrote Rep. Dan Bishop, R-N.C., in a repost of Townhall’s tweet.
"Biden wants Americans to pay ‘their fair share for gas,’" added commentator Benny Johnson, who works for Turning Point USA and hosts a show on Newsmax.
"Paying historic prices at the gas station is just a way to pay your fair share, Michiganders!" the official Michigan GOP account said. "This is what Democrat ‘leadership’ looks and sounds like."
Within the hour, a White House official jumped into the conversation.
"Lazy, deceptive, editing by @townhallcom," said Mike Gwin, the White House’s rapid response director, in a tweet a little more than 30 minutes after the Townhall post went up. Gwin’s tweet included a longer video showing the final part of Biden’s sentence that the Townhall clip left out.
Lazy, deceptive, editing by @townhallcom to omit that the President was noting falling gas prices, and actually said:
— Mike Gwin (@MGwin46) December 8, 2021
"We're making progress, we're going to keep at it to ensure American people are paying their fair share for gas **not being gouged for gas**” https://t.co/MEHxU2ecmW pic.twitter.com/pYQYX9vj1v
Soon after, the Post Millennial deleted its tweet, and so did Disclose.tv.
But Townhall kept its video up. And though it omitted Biden saying "not being gouged by gas," the clip went on to receive nearly 117,000 views on Twitter in a day’s time. It was shared by numerous Republican members of Congress, including Sen. Marsha Blackburn, R-Tenn.
A version of the abbreviated clip even reached Fox News, where host Laura Ingraham played it for her viewers as she handed off to late-night host Greg Gutfeld on Dec. 8.
In response to an inquiry from PolitiFact, a Townhall spokesperson said the outlet was "directly quoting the president in our tweet," and that the website had added an extended video showing Biden’s complete remarks on gas prices in a thread under its original tweet. The follow-up tweet wrongly claimed that omitting Biden’s final words did not change the meaning of his sentence.
Our Sources
Facebook posts, Dec. 8, 2021
Instagram posts, Dec. 8, 2021
Media Research Center on Facebook (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
Townhall on Twitter (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
Fox News, "Gutfeld!" Dec. 8, 2021
Students for Trump on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Congressman Mike Carey on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Congressman Jim Hagedorn on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Judge Carter on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Rep. Barry Moore on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Pete Stauber on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Sen. Marsha Blackburn on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
David B. McKinley on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Ashley Hinson on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Newsbusters on Facebook (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
The Post Millennial on Twitter (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
Disclose.tv on Twitter (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
Benny Johnson on Twitter (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
Michigan GOP on Twitter (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
Dan Bishop on Twitter (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
Mike Gwin on Twitter (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
CrowdTangle, accessed Dec. 9, 2021
Hoaxy, accessed Dec. 9, 2021
TVEyes, accessed Dec. 9, 2021
The White House, "Remarks by President Biden on How the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law Delivers for Missourians" (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
PBS Newshour on YouTube, "WATCH LIVE: Biden gives remarks on bipartisan infrastructure law in Kansas City, MO," Dec. 8, 2021
LeadStories, "Fact Check: Biden 'Fair Share' Clip Omits 'Not Being Gouged' From Gas Price Remarks," Dec. 8, 2021
Email correspondence with Mike Gwin, White House director of rapid response, Dec. 9, 2021
Facebook posts, Dec. 8, 2021
Instagram posts, Dec. 8, 2021
Media Research Center on Facebook (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
Townhall on Twitter (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
Fox News, "Gutfeld!" Dec. 8, 2021
Students for Trump on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Congressman Mike Carey on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Congressman Jim Hagedorn on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Judge Carter on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Rep. Barry Moore on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Pete Stauber on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Sen. Marsha Blackburn on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
David B. McKinley on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Ashley Hinson on Twitter (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
Newsbusters on Facebook (archived), Dec. 9, 2021
The Post Millennial on Twitter (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
Disclose.tv on Twitter (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
Benny Johnson on Twitter (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
Michigan GOP on Twitter (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
Dan Bishop on Twitter (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
Mike Gwin on Twitter (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
CrowdTangle, accessed Dec. 9, 2021
Hoaxy, accessed Dec. 9, 2021
TVEyes, accessed Dec. 9, 2021
The White House, "Remarks by President Biden on How the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law Delivers for Missourians" (archived), Dec. 8, 2021
PBS Newshour on YouTube, "WATCH LIVE: Biden gives remarks on bipartisan infrastructure law in Kansas City, MO," Dec. 8, 2021
LeadStories, "Fact Check: Biden 'Fair Share' Clip Omits 'Not Being Gouged' From Gas Price Remarks," Dec. 8, 2021
Email correspondence with Mike Gwin, White House director of rapid response, Dec. 9, 2021
Email correspondence with Erika Haas, spokesperson for Townhall, Dec. 9, 2021